Light Comparison

Article Submitted by Adam O’Quinn

I thought I’d do a quick and informal comparison of the lights I have on hand.  Distance to the trash can was 25 yards.

 

First up is a 80 lumen Surefire 6P LED

 

Surefire 6P

 

 

Surefire G2Z with a drop in 220 lumen Q5 Cree LED lamp

 

Surefire G2Z

 

 

Surefire 6P with the 65 lumen incandescent bulb

 

Surefire 6P

 

 

Surefire X200A 60 lumen pistol light

 

Surefire X200A

 

 

Finally a 200 lumen Surefire M600C Scout Light

 

Surefire Scout Light M600C

 

 

 

So what conclusions can be drawn?

 

Well, the more light the better.  Revolutionary idea I know.

 

I would consider 200 lumens to be the minimum necessary for a rifle mounted weapon light.  Anything less isn’t going to allow for positive target ID at any real distance.

 

If anyone is still running a 65 lumen incandescent light on their rifle I would strongly urge them to upgrade as there are far better and more capable options out there nowadays.

 

If found for the right (low) price on the used market, the now discontinued X200 could still be useful as a light on a home defense bed side pistol, otherwise spring for the far more capable X300.

 

The Q5 Cree drop in LED lamp is a viable option for upgrading older 6P and G2 lights.  It dramatically increases the light output with hardly any decrease in battery life.  I’ve been using one in the G2Z light I carry at work for a year now and have no complaints.  It’s held up well to the everyday wear and tear and occasional drops that come with being a work tool.  It’s also given me a far brighter light in a far smaller package than the Streamlights most of my co workers carry.

 

Adam

One thought on “Light Comparison”

  1. Only plus side to the incandescent is the ability to run an IR filter if using some kind of night vision.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s